Perceptions of Psychological Intimate Partner Violence: The Influence of Sexual Minority Stigma and Childhood Exposure to Domestic Violence among Bisexual and Lesbian Women · Islam S

4. Discussion

Theoretically informed by the minority stress, social exchange, and social-ecological perspectives, this study sought to investigate the linkages between sexual minority stigma and perceptions of psychological IPV among self-identifying bisexual and lesbian women. With specific interest in the more common but less understood form of IPV that comprises psychological tactics of power and control, the results represent a contribution to the literature that has focused on physical IPV in heterosexual couples.

Results for the first research question demonstrated significant, positive associations that differed between bisexual and lesbian women. Perceived and enacted sexual minority stigmas represent external or more distal sources of stigma [5,47]. These two subtypes of external sexual minority stigma were significantly correlated with perceptions of psychological IPV. These findings somewhat align with the literature on IPV that links behavioral correlates of IPV with experiences of discrimination among bisexual and lesbian women [4]. A more recent review of sexual minority stigma measures demonstrates that the general evidence of a connection to IPV risk is mostly unclear, however [49]. It is important to distinguish that the current study did not examine IPV perpetration and victimization. The discrepancy between existing studies that show a relationship between sexual minority discrimination (or external sexual minority stigma) and IPV behavior [4,50] and the current study findings of a lack of a relationship between external sexual minority stigma and perceptions of psychological IPV may indicate differences between behaviors and perceptions that are worthy of further exploration.

A number of studies show positive relationships between internalized sexual minority stigma and physical, sexual, and psychological IPV [4,27,29]. Specific evidence of this pattern among bisexual and lesbian women demonstrates that increased levels of internalized sexual minority stigma were related to disclosing a history of IPV victimization and perpetration [4]. Indeed, the current study found that internalized sexual minority stigma was significantly and positively correlated with perceptions of psychological IPV for bisexual women. In navigating favorable and unfavorable outcomes, the significance of personal and public perceptions of psychological IPV appears to suggest a fruitful grounding of social exchange theory. While there is no evidence to speculate further, there may be nuanced effects of sexual minority stigma in assessing alternatives that may help to explain the differences between bisexual and lesbian women. Intimate relationships and access to resources, both physical and psychological, may be more limited for bisexual women who may feel doubly isolated from heterosexual and lesbian peers. Subsequent research on sexual minority stigma and potential tolerance of psychological IPV alongside personal resources is essential.

Additional research suggests that bisexual and lesbian women who may have internalized the negativity associated with their sexual minority identity may also endorse stigmatization of others [37,51]. The ensuing impact of self-hatred may shape beliefs that psychological IPV is not so problematic or intensify awareness that the characters in the scenarios may have scarcer options. This may have profound effects on bisexual and lesbian women who may tolerate their own victimization or project their internalized stigma onto their partners and other sexual minority people [51]. The psychological IPV that occurs within sexual minority couples may then keep individuals from accessing help-seeking resources especially within the heteronormative environment. The extent of exposure to domestic violence in childhood for both partners may have an additive impact and heighten tolerance for the psychological IPV portrayed in the vignettes. A more contextualized framing of IPV with concern to perceptions of tolerance and permissiveness is merited to map out the particular insidious role of internalized sexual minority stigma.

Results for the second and third research aims did not yield any significant moderation effects. This unanticipated observation suggests that, among the main variables of interest in the current study, effects of the proposed moderators were the same across groups. Pertaining to childhood exposure to domestic violence, four types of domestic violence were assessed: witnessing physical forms of domestic violence, being physically harmed, being psychologically harmed, and being sexually harmed. Existing research tends to draw upon early exposure to household violence and dysfunction as key predictors in negative health outcomes [52,53]; conceived as distal stressors, child abuse experiences, specifically sexual abuse, may have a uniquely depleting influence on permissive perceptions of psychological IPV. Unfortunately, the differentiation between bisexual and lesbian women is understudied in this literature. Current findings of bisexual women reporting significantly more psychological victimization and lesbian women reporting significantly more sexual victimization should be extended to larger study samples optimized for addressing greater nuance across groups.

Similarly, there was no indication of the moderating role of sexual orientation. This finding is rather inconsistent with the accumulating literature indicating that bisexual women experience elevated health risks and outcomes, including IPV victimization as well as IPV victimization by type [10]. The measures of sexual minority stigma in the present study did not explicitly address binegativity, however. The findings may potentially be obscured and reflect feedback that is a partial representation of their experiences. In addition, the vignettes featured women in same-gender relationships. As expected, bisexual women were less likely to report having had an adult intimate relationship with a woman. Bisexual women also tended to have lower socioeconomic statuses relative to lesbian women, where the latter reported higher income, economic resources, and education levels. Such demographic variations may be associated with differing judgements; it may be that relationship status and history rendered bisexual women to be more disapproving of the psychological IPV depicted in the scenarios.

Regarding group comparisons, lesbian women reported higher levels of perceived and enacted sexual minority stigmas, whereas bisexual women reported higher levels of internalized sexual minority stigma. There is a compelling body of literature identifying the harmful experiences with sexual minority stigma singular to bisexual women. Binary notions of sexual attraction may be affirmed by the dominant heterosexist group and sexual minority groups, vilifying bisexual women [38,39,54,55]. This independent source of stigma has been linked to perceived exclusion, hostility, and stereotyping [37,55] and may suggest that confounding variables may preclude a clearer understanding of the present findings. For example, visibility may be a relevant aspect in how stigma is perceived and experienced and, consequently, internalized. Bisexual women already contend with binegativity and monosexism [38], and there may be instances where they are more protected from external sexual minority stigma if their intimate partners are men. In this same way, lesbian women whose relationships with other women may be more visible, might face increased targeting from external sources of stigma. Factors related to sexual and romantic partners (e.g., gender) may better clarify perceptions of psychological IPV in scenarios with same- and different-gender couples.

Study Limitations and Suggestions for Future Research

The current study had several limitations. First, the cross-sectional nature of data collection limits the examination of temporal and directional relationships. Identifying whether sexual minority stigma precedes, co-occurs, or follows permissive judgments about psychological IPV is necessary to enrich understanding of these complex variables. Second, purposive sampling procedures weaken the generalizability of the study findings; nonetheless, this strategy was advantageous for recruiting self-identified bisexual and lesbian women. Third, the measurement of permissive perceptions of psychological IPV has not been validated and requires additional testing. Prior to the study, however, the vignettes were assessed for face validity through expert review, and correlations between the three vignettes were positive and significant (r = 0.46, r = 0.38, r = 0.35, p < 0.01) in the present study. In addition, the study participants were prompted to provide qualitative information to describe why they assigned their ratings for each character. While several responses were unintelligible or left blank, the majority of the sample did attempt to explain their decisions even if they were not consistently answering for every character or scenario. Exploration of these data will strengthen the scope of interpretations of the constructed contexts of psychological IPV, conclusions drawn from the tested vignettes, and issues surrounding couple dynamics [56]. Similarly, focus groups with bisexual and lesbian women who are survivors of psychological IPV may enhance the relevancy and believability of the narratives and, subsequently, overcome barriers associated with hypothetical scenarios [56].

Differences in permissive perceptions of psychological IPV that may be associated with sexual minority stress is a gap that must be addressed in future research. Survey scales inquired about direct experiences of sexual minority stigma and feelings towards being a bisexual or lesbian woman; the degree to which each measure of sexual minority stigma produced stress for the participant was not evaluated. It is also important to consider that some SMW may not perceive encounters with sexual minority stigma to be stressful, but such experiences may still confer negative effects [10]. Nevertheless, potential pathways through which stress levels contribute to tolerant and permissive attitudes towards psychological IPV are key data for defining future research.

Further, the pervasive nature of binegativity as an added source of sexual minority stigma is noteworthy [5,39,55,57]; bisexual women, in comparison to lesbian women, tend to have markedly higher levels of identity uncertainty, fewer connections to the sexual minority communities, and lower levels of outness [57,58]. Given these various sources of discord, bisexual women may be less perceptive in recognizing external sexual minority stigma than lesbian women. Discrimination and harassment may still bear harm to mental and physical health, but the stigma rooted in these events may not be as apparent to bisexual women managing an array of proximal stressors. Despite theoretical and empirical support suggesting that bisexual women may be more likely to report higher levels of sexual minority stigma, lesbian women may possess greater awareness of external sexual minority stigma. Perhaps lesbian women benefit from a social connectivity that bisexual women sometimes lack, and through this, lesbian women are better equipped to label their experiences through a sexual minority stigma lens [45,59].

Future research should employ measures that consider monosexism. The external sexual minority stigma subscales in the current study contain some items that explicitly ask about discrimination, harassment, and violence that comes from “straight” people [47]. Other items do not make this exact differentiation; however, the open-endedness in the wording of such items may have primed the sample to respond similarly by considering perceived and enacted sexual minority stigmas received from heterosexual people. Therefore, the lack of sensitivity in capturing experiences of stigma from sexual minority peers is acknowledged. Special attention to stigma sources may better encapsulate the non-binary sexual orientation of bisexual women and clarify the impact of binegativity on perceptions of psychological IPV.

It will be important to consider the role of other marginalized identities that coexist with the lesbian and bisexual identity, such as racial and ethnic differences that have been highlighted in IPV research among heterosexual couples [5,60]. The ways in which a minority status outside of sexual orientation is stigmatized through discrimination, rejection, and harassment should be analyzed for a more complete understanding of perceptions of psychological IPV. For example, racism may overlap with sexual minority stigma and influence bisexual and lesbian women to rely on their intimate relationships within an environment with minimal support and alternatives.