Caregiver and Juvenile Justice Personnel Perspectives on challenges and importance of caregiver engagement and the potential utility of a peer navigator program in the Juvenile Justice System · Dir AL, Pederson C, Khazvand S et al.

Introduction

Caregivers play a central role in youth development, and as such, caregiver involvement is a centerpiece in youth service systems, such as education, child welfare, and mental health service systems. The juvenile justice system, however, is one system that has lagged in adopting a family-centered approach (Burke et al., 2014). Historically, the JJ system has operated broadly under the doctrine of parens patriae, which allows the state to assume a parental role in order to ensure the safety of the youth and the community (Pennell, Shapiro, & Sprigner, 2011). Nonetheless, in the past few decades the system has come to recognize the important role for caregivers in JJ cases (Walker et al., 2015a; Barnert et al., 2020; Burke et al., 2014). In fact, caregiver engagement and family functioning impacts decision-making by law enforcement and court officials across multiple points of system involvement from decisions at initial arrest (i.e., to detain or release home), to adjudication, and during probation or community supervision (Paik, 2017). It is no surprise that juvenile justice leaders identify family engagement as one of the most important – but challenging – system issues (Development Services Group, 2018). The current study explores caregiver and JJ system personnel perspectives of JJ-family collaboration across multiple points of the JJ system in order to inform the development of a peer-based program to improve caregiver engagement across the JJ system. The manuscript also underscores existing literature highlighting caregiver experiences in JJ.

The Sequential Intercept Model (SIM) outlines the different stages of system involvement from initial contact with law enforcement to initial hearings to community supervision or probation (Munetz & Griffin, 2006). The SIM has been used as a tool to facilitate community-based solutions to support individuals involved in both adult and juvenile justice system (Cintrón Hernández, 2015; Heilburn et al., 2017); it can also be used as an organizational framework to more closely examine different stages of system involvement. The current study focuses on the intercepts of initial arrest / intake, court, and probation because these intercepts require family participation in youth system involvement, unlike detention or placement where youth are removed from the family. Because probation is the most commonly assigned disposition within the system, it is important to capture perspectives on a common opportunity for partnerships between JJ staff and families (Fountain & Mahmoudi, 2021).