Method
Qualitative interviews were conducted with JJ personnel (n = 7), members of a family advisory board (n = 5), and caregivers of youth (n = 15) currently involved in the JJ system. JJ personnel from one Midwestern urban county were recruited to participate using convenience and snowball sampling (n = 1 judge; n = 1 probation officer supervisor; n = 1 intake supervisor; n = 1 probation officer; n = 2 intake probation officers). The authors partnered with an existing family advisory board called FCC that was formed to advise the local juvenile court in their efforts to better understand and improve family experiences with the JJ system. Advisory board members included caregivers of youth previously involved in the JJ system (no caregivers had youth with JJ involvement in the past 5 years) and service providers who work closely with families impacted by the JJ system; all active members agreed to participate in the study. Caregivers of youth currently involved in the JJ system were recruited from the urban county (n = 2) as well as two other rural counties (n = 13) in Indiana given the research team’s JJ system connections in these counties. The two rural counties were included in participant recruitment efforts due to low recruitment in the urban county; the COVID-19 pandemic limited access to and availability of participants when the interviews were being conducted. All procedures were approved by the IRB.
Qualitative interviews
Semi-structured interview guides focused on understanding (1) caregivers’ experiences in the juvenile justice system; (2) relationships between JJ personnel and caregivers; and (3) perspectives on a peer-based program for caregivers to help them navigate the JJ system. Separate interview guides were developed for JJ personnel, caregivers, and fFCC members with overlapping, related questions. Caregiver semi-structured interview guides highlighted facilitators and barriers to navigating the system from initial arrest to adjudication to probation, nature of relationships with JJ personnel, suggestions for improving experiences, and suggestions and opinions regarding a potential peer-based navigator program. System personnel interview guides highlighted perspectives on the role of caregivers in JJ cases, facilitators and barriers to building relationships with caregivers and families, and suggestions and opinions for a navigator program. Interview guides with FCC members addressed perspectives on family engagement in the JJ system as well as perspectives regarding a navigator program. Qualitative interviews with participants were audio recorded and transcribed verbatim for coding.
Analysis
Transcribed interviews were uploaded to MAXQDA for coding and analysis. We conducted thematic analysis utilizing a phenomenological framework, such that we focused on capturing caregivers’ and JJ personnel’s lived experiences through the interviews (Sundler et al., 2019; Braun & Clarke, 2006). Qualitative codes were developed using a combination of (1) a priori categories based on the research questions and previous research on JJ-caregiver relationships and (2) themes that were identified through inductive review of the interview transcripts. Initial coding by the first author was conducted to develop a set of initial codes. Next, first and second authors conducted additional initial coding with a subset of transcripts to develop a final set of codes. Finally, focused coding with all transcripts was conducted with the first and second author; coders met frequently throughout to ensure reliability. Following coding, demographics of participants were examined for potential patterns in responses, and coding was also examined for patterns in responses from JJ and parents.
CC BY 4.0. "Caregiver and Juvenile Justice Personnel Perspectives on challenges and importance of caregiver engagement and the potential utility of a peer navigator program in the Juvenile Justice System" by Dir AL, Pederson C, Khazvand S et al., Health & justice (2023). https://doi.org/10.1186/s40352-023-00231-y. Licensed under CC BY 4.0 (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/). Peer-reviewed and open access; full text from PubMed Central (PMC10403869). Headings and layout adapted for reading; figures and tables are in the original.