Discussion
We sought to examine perspectives of both JJ personnel and caregivers of youth involved in JJ to understand relationships between JJ personnel and caregivers and challenges to system engagement, as well as perspectives on the potential utility of a peer-based navigator program to support caregivers in the system.
Findings highlight the potential acceptability and utility of a peer navigator program to support caregivers involved in the JJ system. In general, both caregivers and JJ personnel identified that a parent navigator program could provide all aspects of social support: emotional support (care, empathy trust), instrumental support (provision of concrete assistance), informational support, and appraisal support (affirming or validating support) (Hingson et al., 1990). These perspectives on benefits of the program are consistent with findings from actual evaluations of navigator programs which have shown increases in caregiver self-efficacy and agency in navigating systems (evidence of appraisal and informational support; Walker et al., 2015b), improved social and concrete supports (evidence of instrumental support; Gottlieb et al., 2016; January et al., 2015), and reduced system frustration (evidence of emotional support; Myers et al., 2015; Markoulakis et al., 2018) (emotional support). Despite the largely positive perspectives of the program, both caregivers and JJ personnel did caution that the program may be unwelcome for some who may perceive navigators as meddling in their role as a caregiver or may perceive it as a burden and an additional court requirement. Given these findings, a next step includes developing a program in partnership with the FCC and piloting the program.
Findings also corroborate and replicate previous research regarding caregivers’ experiences with the system. Broadly, both caregivers and JJ personnel agreed that the experience of system involvement depends on the point of contact with the system, with unique considerations at intake or initial arrest, court, and probation. Intake and initial arrest were primarily characterized by frustration, stress, and surprise. Court was largely characterized as a negative experience, with caregivers feeling as if they did not have a voice and judged for their child’s behavior. Probation experiences were more variable, with some reporting positive experiences and others reporting negative experiences. Those who had positive experiences felt heard and supported, while those with negative experiences felt burdened by probation requirements and did not feel the process was helping their child. Such findings are consistent with previous caregiver reports of system experiences (Justice for Families, 2012; Osher and Shufelt, 2006). These findings emphasize the need to continue to closely examine experiences of families during different stages of the JJ system.
The SIM is an ideal tool to utilize to better select and tailor interventions designed to improve caregiver and family experiences and facilitate engagement at these different points in the system. For instance, while interventions to improve family engagement at the time of arrest may include emphathizing with caregiver surprise and finding more agreeable ways to ask personal information (e.g., questionnaire as opposed to a verbal interview), interventions at the court level may include preparing caregivers for their role in court or providing specified time during court for parents to share their perspectives (Walker et al., 2015b). Both caregivers and JJ personnel highlighted potential benefits of a navigator program that could assuage these negative experiences at different points in the system through provision of social support. In fact, there is already evidence for the use of navigators in court (Walker et al., 2015b) as well as as a linkage facilitator during probation (Elkington et al., 2022); findings inform that a navigator that follows families across their system involvement starting as early as the point of initial intake following arrest or referral may be most beneficial.
Caregiver confusion and uncertaintly around navigating the system was common across all points of JJ contact, consistent with previous research (Cleary & Warner, 2017; Cleveland & Quas, 2018; Justice for Families, 2012; Osher and Shufelt, 2006). Indeed, the juvenile legal system utilizes unique terminology and processes that seem separate from other service sections (e.g., school, healthcare) even if intrinsically linked (e.g., school resource officers, high behavioral health need amongst JJ involved youth). However, while caregivers may expect and become practiced in navigating the healthcare system by going to a pediatrician’s office for yearly check-ups or the school system through routine attendance and enrollment, caregivers likely do not expect their child to become involved in the JJ system, and, are thus, unlikely to have or seek out a priori knowledge prior to their child’s arrest. Furthermore, JJ system involvement is a relatively rare occurrence compared to involvement in other child-serving systems, and thus, caregivers likely do not have opportunities to learn from other caregivers, family, and friends how the system works. This highlights a critical role for a peer navigator whose first-hand knowledge is invaluable and consistent with caregiver and JJ personnel perspectives on the benefits of a navigator.
One common theme noted at all points in JJ were experiences of feeling judged, blamed, and punished for their child’s system involvement. In fact, even JJ personnel acknowledged caregivers’ sentiments of blame. These findings are consistent with empirical findings on families’ and system personnel reports of experiences within the JJ system (e.g., Amani et al., 2018; Hillian and Reitsma-Street, 2003; Justice for Families, 2012; Ravoira et al., 2012). It may be helpful to consider the ethics framework of procedural justice, which emphasizes that those going through the system feel heard, are treated with respect, and are given a voice within the system (Hough et al., 2010). Beliefs that the legal system has treated them in a procedurally just manner has shown benefits (e.g., reduced recidivism; institutional compliance) for both adults and youth involved in the system (e.g., Aarons et al., 2015; Beijersbergen et al., 2016; Bierie, 2013; Brown et al., 2019; Kupchik and Snyder, 2009), but to our knowledge this framework has yet to be applied to caregivers with youth involved in the JJ system. Findings from the current study reveal the potential utility in applying a procedural justice framework to caregiver involvement in the juvenile legal system, especially given that caregivers’ views of constructs consistent with a procedurally just judicial system seem to be lacking (e.g., lack of voice and respect for their views). It is possible that user of a navigator to provide such appraisal support may increasweFuture research may benefit from using a procedural justice framework to not only understand caregiver experiences but also guide interventions, such as navigators, to improve caregiver experiences with the system.
Findings also point to the importance that the JJ system places on family engagement and the intersection of caregiver expectations of JJ and JJ expectations of caregivers. Reports regarding JJ expectations of caregivers’ involvement suggested that caregivers were viewed as critical to successful legal case resolution, while on the other hand, caregivers perceived their involvement as a burden and a punishment they received alongside their child. This severe disconnect between JJ personnel and caregivers underscores the critical need for better communication, which was even highlighted by JJ personnel. Interestingly, while JJ personnel and caregivers were not on the same page regarding the expectations they had for each other, they were remarkably consistent in identifying similar barriers for building a strong JJ-caregiver partnership. This finding is encouraging, as this would suggest that the problems are known and understood, allowing for ready identification of potential solutions. Such conflict also speaks to the use of a navigator to serve as a mediator between JJ personnel and caregivers to improve communication and understanding between both parties.
It is also important to note that the majority of caregivers and all FCC members identified as Black, while all JJ personnel identified as White. This discrepancy underscores the disproportionate minority contact and structural discrimination that persists across JJ systems. Many of the themes noted by both JJ personnel and caregivers are, in part, a product of structural discrimination. As such, it is likely that solutions such as a navigator program may allay the negative experiences of some families without addressing the root causes of family disengagement. This points to a potentially important role of the navigators to also serve as advocates of system change and to to bring attention to these system-level issues.
The study is not without limitations. The manuscript is lacking perspectives of actual youth involved in JJ; such perspectives are important to understand JJ’s perspectives on the role of caregiver involvement and how this may impact their own experiences and their case. We sampled individuals from two rural counties and an urban county. Although our results revealed similar experiences across jurisdictions, contextual system differences may have influenced responses. Though the small sample size may limit generalizability, we did achieve thematic saturation through qualitative interviews. Additionally, when considering improvements in caregiver engagement, it is important to ensure that solutions are tailored to local, population-specific characteristics. For the current study, perspectives from advisory board members, caregivers involved in the system, and JJ personnel from the urban county – although limited in number – provide important first-hand information for development of the program in this jurisdiction. All JJ personnel were White while the majority of caregivers and all FCC members were Black; while this reality may limit generalizability, our sample was representative of the populations of interest. Future research should explore how race and ethnicity of JJ personnel and caregivers impact experiences and relationships.
CC BY 4.0. "Caregiver and Juvenile Justice Personnel Perspectives on challenges and importance of caregiver engagement and the potential utility of a peer navigator program in the Juvenile Justice System" by Dir AL, Pederson C, Khazvand S et al., Health & justice (2023). https://doi.org/10.1186/s40352-023-00231-y. Licensed under CC BY 4.0 (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/). Peer-reviewed and open access; full text from PubMed Central (PMC10403869). Headings and layout adapted for reading; figures and tables are in the original.