JJ System Perspectives on Caregiver Engagement
Much of the literature on JJ system perspectives of caregiver engagement has focused on JJ system expectations of caregivers and how family characteristics play a role in court and JJ system decision-making.
Court-level decision-making
Caregiver engagement at the level of court proceedings is important. There has been a long history of courts holding caregivers responsible for youth behavior, and many state laws continue to hold parents responsible and accountable for youth behavior (Harvell et al., 2004). Although caregivers are perceived as passive participants with minimal interaction (Peterson-Badali & Broeking, 2010; Smith et al., 2009), family characteristics and caregiver engagement influence court decision-making. For example, when a family member is present at court, the court is more likely to release youth to the home (Peterson-Badali & Broeking, 2009, 2010). Family characteristics also influence court decisions; for instance, there is evidence that harsher decisions are given at initial arrest and case disposition for youth in single-parent households (Leiber & Mack, 2003; Love & Morris, 2019).
Community supervision and probation decision-making
There is more available research on system-level perspectives of caregiver engagement at the level of community supervision (i.e., probation); much of this research highlights the challenges of and strategies for establishing collaborative partnerships with caregivers. Commonly reported challenges to engaging caregivers in probation range from practical barriers to complying with probation requirements (e.g., lack of resources, such as transportation) to caregiver attitudes that hinder developing a partnership for probation (Maschi et al., 2013; Schwalbe & Maschi, 2010a, b). One study of probation officers described challenges such as caregivers not understanding or agreeing with the need for probation requirements, as well as caregivers being unwilling to partner with probation officers in the process (e.g., not responding to communications) (Maschi et al., 2013). In another qualitative study, JJ caseworkers recognized how caregivers’ feelings of powerlessness can create a barrier to their active engagement with probation (Sattler & Thomas, 2016).
Other studies examining JJ personnel perspectives have typically focused on JJ personnel expectations for the role of caregivers in JJ cases. In general, across court personnel, probation officers, and police, findings emphasize the importance of caregivers in being present and involved in court or probation meetings and the impact that this has on JJ decision-making. One study identified characteristics of an “ideal parent,” which included caregiver ability to support their child (i.e., provide emotional support, help youth meet court obligations), assert parental authority (i.e., enforce discipline, utilize appropriate parental monitoring), and partner with probation officers in the probation process (i.e., participate in case planning, enforce youth’s compliance with probation requirements) (Maschi et al., 2013). Such characteristics are consistent with other research that has emphasized JJ personnel’s perspectives that caregivers should actively partner with court personnel and provide parental monitoring and supervision (Peterson-Badali & Broeking, 2010).
Caregiver perspectives
Research on caregiver experiences with the JJ system is also well documented; however, much of the large scale studies of caregiver experiences are dated (e.g., Justice for Families, 2012; Osher and Shufelt, 2006). Also, much of the research on caregivers has focused on understanding parenting practices – such as parental monitoring and support – as it relates to the behavior of their child (Cook, 2013; Cook & Gordon, 2012; Folk et al., 2020; Cavanagh & Cauffman, 2017; Jones et al., 2007).
Caregivers and the Court
Regarding court experiences, two large national studies have highlighted caregiver experiences of the court process. Across studies, caregivers report that court is associated with emotional stress and feeling blamed for their child’s involvement (Justice for Families, 2012; Osher and Shufelt, 2006). Studies also highlight that court is a rather confusing process and many caregivers do not know what is going on or what to expect in court, which creates additional stress (Hillian & Reitma-Street, 2003; Justice for Families, 2012; Osher and Shufelt, 2006). Lastly, families highlighted that they did not feel involved in the court decision-making process and were not given the opportunity to speak during court or provide feedback (Justice for Families, 2012; Osher and Shufelt, 2006).
Caregivers and probation
Despite one goal of probation to be a relationship between families and probation officers (Maschi et al., 2013; Vidal & Woolard, 2016), caregivers face many challenges with probation. In a multi-state study examining caregiver experiences with the JJ system, many caregivers felt that probation was a “fast-track” to deeper involvement within the system (Justice for Families, 2012). Across studies, caregivers describe feeling burdened by probation requirements as well as experiencing financial strain that comes with court and probation fees and requirements (Justice for Families, 2012; Models for Change, 2009). Probation involvement can lead to caregivers feeling punished and looked down upon (Luckenbill & Yeager, 2009a, b; Osher & Shufelt, 2006; Ravoira et al., 2012). With that said, one study found that caregivers generally had positive relationships with probation officers, which they characterized as fair, supportive, and helpful towards their children; moreover, positive views of probation officers were associated with parental compliance with probation (Vidal & Woolard, 2016). This is consistent with overarching messages from caregivers regarding the importance of feeling respected and understood by the JJ system (Models for Change, 2009).
System issues such as disproportionate minority contact and structural discrimination as also impact caregivers’ experiences with the JJ system and willingness to engage with JJ personnel (Amani et al., 2018; Fountain & Mahmoudi, 2021). For one, youth of color are significantly overrepresented in the JJ system and are detained at higher rates than White youth (Rovner, 2016). Structural inequalities in the law and the system remain, such that well-intentioned system efforts to focus on family engagement – such as requiring parenting classes – have unfortunately resulted in more blame and responsibility placed on families of color and appear to perpetuate biased treatment (Amani et al., 2018; Piquero, 2008). Other structural barriers that disproportionately impact racial/ethnic minorities make it challenging for youth and families of color to comply with system requirements, in turn leading to deeper system involvement (Fountain & Mahmoudi, 2021). Such inequities contribute to lack of trust and credibility of the system, which further impedes efforts to establish positive JJ-family partnerships (e.g., Amani et al., 2018; Hillian & Reitma-Street, 2003; Vidal and Woolard, 2016).
Family Engagement efforts
Given the importance and challenges of caregiver engagement, significant efforts to improve engagement have been made (Burke et al., 2014; Walker et al., 2012; Walker et al., 2015a). For example, in an effort to increase caregiver engagement, supplemental grant funding for courts to administer extrajudicial programs is often contingent upon the provision of evidence-based family-based services (Walker et al., 2015a). Other efforts to improve family engagement have included additional training of court personnel as well as implementation of family-centered treatment models that address not only parenting skills but also ecological and environmental factors impacting youth (Walker et al., 2015a; Robertson et al., 2019).
The current study explores the potential use of one such strategy – peer-led system navigators – as a way to increase caregiver engagement with the JJ system. Peer navigation models involve utilizing individuals with shared culture or previous/lived experience navigating systems to provide emotional, social, and informational support to those currently involved in a system; such models have been used in a number of youth-serving systems including mental health and medical systems (Godoy et al., 2019; Lammers et al., 2019; Nayak et al., 2022). Evaluations of family navigator programs have shown promise in use of navigators to increase caregiver social and concrete support (Gottlieb et al., 2016; January et al., 2015), reduce caregiver frustrations with the mental health system (Markoulakis et al., 2018; Myers et al., 2015), and reduce time to service connection (Broder-Fingert et al., 2020; Feinberg et al., 2021). Given the aforementioned challenges that caregivers involved in JJ face, such a model could address some of these issues.
The use of peer navigation models have been implemented in a limited number of jurisdictions in the JJ system. One such program, called Juvenile Justice 101, provides support to caregivers during the court process; a randomized trial of JJ 101 found that use of navigators increased caregivers’ self-efficacy in navigating JJ court processes (Walker et al., 2015b). The Parent Support Program (PSP) was developed in New York City and offers support (emotional, informational, connection to resources) to caregivers across multiple stages of system involvement starting with court; in an unpublished evaluation of the program, they found that caregivers engaged in PSP reported increased sense of agency and understanding of JJ system procedures, and families involved in PSP had better JJ case outcomes compared to those in the control group (i.e., lower rates of out-of-home placements and probation violations) (Impact Justice, 2019). Family Connect targets youth on probation and helping families connect to needed behavioral health services through utilizing trained linkage facilitators (not peers) who had training and knowledge of the behavioral health system (Elkington et al., 2022). A pilot trial demonstrated evidence for feasibility and acceptability of the program (Elkington et al., 2022). Other similar programs, such as use of family advocates, have been utilized in other states like Pennsylvania (Models for Change, 2009); however, empirical research on effectiveness is lacking.
The current study adds to the existing literature on caregiver experiences of JJ involvement (see Justice for Families, 2012) by examining both caregiver and JJ personnel perspectives on the facilitators and barriers to establishing collaborative JJ-caregiver relationships at multiple points across the JJ system. Caregiver experiences are documented in the literature (Osher & Shufelt, 2006; Justice for Families, 2012); however, most research has been published over 10 years asgo, and no studies have directly compared caregiver and JJ personnel perspectives. Such research is critical in order to inform needed system-level changes to improve family engagement in JJ. Moreover, the primary goal of the study is to utilize findings in order to inform the development of a caregiver navigator program with the goal of increasing caregiver support and engagement with the JJ system. Interviews provide information on experiences of JJ personnel and caregivers as well as their perspectives on the potential use of a peer navigator program.
CC BY 4.0. "Caregiver and Juvenile Justice Personnel Perspectives on challenges and importance of caregiver engagement and the potential utility of a peer navigator program in the Juvenile Justice System" by Dir AL, Pederson C, Khazvand S et al., Health & justice (2023). https://doi.org/10.1186/s40352-023-00231-y. Licensed under CC BY 4.0 (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/). Peer-reviewed and open access; full text from PubMed Central (PMC10403869). Headings and layout adapted for reading; figures and tables are in the original.