Results
Of the n = 15 caregivers interviewed, 53% (n = 8) identified as White, 47% as Black (n = 7), 6% as Hispanic (n = 1), and 93% (n = 14) as female (caregivers’ youth ages ranged 14–17, M = 16 years). All caregivers had already experienced adjudication through the JJ system and the majority of caregivers’ youth were currently on probation. Of JJ personnel (n = 7), 100% identified as White and 50% identified as female. JJ personnel represented intake (n = 1 intake supervisor; n = 2 intake officers), court (n = 1 judge), probation (n = 1 probation officer, n = 1 probation supervisor), and diversion (n = 1 diversion program officer/coordinator). All FCC members (n = 5) identified as Black and female (n = 3 members had children previously involved in the JJ system). There were no differences in patterns of caregiver demographics or responses (i.e., qualitative themes) across urban and rural counties. Below we describe emergent themes related to caregiver and JJ experiences as well as perspectives on the development of a peer-based navigator program for caregivers. Additional quotes highlighting themes are presented in Table 1.
Caregiver JJ Experiences
Initial arrest / intake
Caregivers reported that the experience of intake and learning of their child’s arrest/referral was a time of high emotion and stress, with caregivers describing feelings ranging from frustration and anger to confusion, shock, and concern. Caregivers explained how the process was overwhelming and many voiced confusion and uncertainty as to how to navigate the process. Caregivers also noted feeling as though the initial intake was somewhat intrusive as they were asked a number of personal questions. As one caregiver explained, “I’m somewhat of a private person and I just feel violated with being asked all these questions because my child got into trouble.” Table 1 presents additional quotes.
Court
Caregivers overwhelmingly described the court experience as a challenging and confusing process. Caregivers noted not knowing what to expect, sometimes not understanding what was going on during the court process, as well as uncertainty in their role during court (e.g., whether they were allowed to speak). For example, one FCC member explained her court experience: “I didn’t know what was happening there…I couldn’t even tell you like how I even knew about court, to be honest.” Others noted feeling judged, undervalued, and as though they were not being heard or given appropriate resources. As one caregiver explained:
I felt like I was being looked down on as a parent. Because you’re always being judged, you know, even if you’re -- because there are a lot of parents out there that just kind of let their kids run wild. I am not one of those. And I felt like I was being met with passive aggressiveness also, when I was there. I did not feel comfortable, I did not feel welcomed.
Other caregivers voiced similar sentiments of feeling judged, undervalued, and unsupported (see Table 1).
Probation experiences
Caregivers described a range of experiences with probation, with some caregivers describing positive experiences with probation and others describing negative experiences.
Positive experiences.
In general, caregivers reporting positive experiences with probation officers described relationships characterized by open communication, respect, and collaboration between probation officers and caregivers to meet family needs (e.g., flexibility with meeting times, requirements). First, open communication included being informed about court and probation expectations and being able to ask questions. One caregiver explained: “We communicated well…he explained everything to where I completely understood. He gave me his card…and he also checked up like once a week to make sure that everything was going well in the household.” Flexibility was also a common factor and included probation officer flexibility and willingness to make accommodations to best fit the needs of the family. For example, some caregivers noted probation officers working with them to find alternative solutions to court requirements during COVID-19 when many programs were not available and being willing to adjust meeting times to meet the family’s needs. Lastly, caregivers endorsing positive experiences highlighted feeling respected by probation officers and feeling as though probation officers were interested in their child’s success. One parent summarized her experience: “The probation department is not your enemy. They’re actually – they want your child to succeed. They’re not your enemy. They’re not trying to fight against you because I know a lot of people look at them negatively.”
Negative experiences.
Those endorsing negative experiences most often reported feeling blamed and punished for their child’s involvement with the system and feeling as though probation officers did not take into account family-related barriers to meeting probation requirements. Caregivers described stress and frustration over their role and responsibility in their child’s probation and feeling that many of the probation requirements fell on them. As one caregiver explained:Ripping and running from work to try to get her to places on time and she’s not, she’s punished, but then again, it’s me being punished. It’s very hectic and stressful. And I don’t think it really helps [my child] because I’m the only one who is straining and struggling, not her.
Other caregivers also felt as though they were being punished for their child’s behavior. One caregiver explained “Like they put it on me, like I’m the fault of the behaviors that happened at school, you know? And that’s where I got this, that blame game that did not sit right with me.” Others reported experiences where probation officers were inflexible and not considering family’s other responsibilities. As one caregiver described:[they said] they would meet me halfway and [do] what we discussed. But at the end, we didn’t meet halfway with what they said, what was going on, this and that about what they wanted to do. Nothing about how I felt, how he felt, how nobody felt.
Table 1 provides additional quotes.
JJ Personnel Perspectives
Initial arrest / intake and court
JJ intake personnel acknowledged that learning of a child’s system involvement can be seen as a time of crisis for caregivers, but that cooperation and communication is important and plays a role in intake and future court decision-making (e.g., whether to detain or release home, whether to divert or send to court). JJ intake personnel explained that often times it can be difficult to communicate and get information from caregivers, as JJ personnel are often perceived as the “system” (i.e., child welfare system) and thus caregivers are hesitant to provide information. One intake supervisor explained, “Partnering with that parent to get as much information as possible to make a good decision…It can be invasive and uncomfortable, and there are parents that don’t want to cooperate and don’t want us in their business.” Intake and court staff also noted that both the intake and court process can be overwhelming and confusing as they are given a lot of information at one time. As one intake officer explained “Many times it’s almost like they hit a brick wall. Like they’re taking in too much at one time and especially if it’s a family that’s not been through the process before.” Nonetheless, intake and court staff emphasized the importance of caregiver presence during the process. One probation officer explained how parent involvement is most crucial during the pretrial stage before sentencing when they have to conduct an assessment/report: “That point is kind of the turning point, where the parent understands what their expectations are and that’s like the last pretrial step before probation.” As one judge summarized the importance of the caregiver’s involvement in the court process, “If the parent isn’t involved, or the caregiver, those kids don’t fair very well. It’s a participatory sport and we really need that person engaged.”
Probation
JJ personnel similarly highlighted the importance of caregiver involvement in the probation process as well as facilitators and barriers to partnerships. JJ personnel explained expectations of a caregiver as acting as a partner with the probation officer to monitor youth, which entails communicating with the probation officer about their child’s behavior as well as helping to facilitate engagement in court requirements (e.g., scheduling therapy appointments, providing transportation). As one probation supervisor explained: “We hear a lot of times ‘I’m not the one on probation, so why are you needing this from me?’; No, you’re technically not on probation, but yes, you pretty much are on probation.”
JJ probation officers described facilitators and barriers to successful JJ-caregiver partnerships. Successful partnerships were described as those in which aforementioned expectations are met. In particular, when there is open communication, caregivers understand their role, and caregivers feel heard. Probation officers noted challenges in partnerships when caregivers perceived them as being “intrusive” or “invasive”, not willing to communicate, and when there was disagreement over the youth’s needs (e.g., caregiver not feeling that therapy is necessary although court-ordered). JJ personnel suggested that challenges to probation were often primarily due to caregiver resistance to the process rather than the actual youth’s resistance to the process. As one intake officer explained in reference to caregivers in the intake and probation process, “A lot of the time that’s where we can get a lot of the pushback, the parent’s willingness to be actively involved in the process, because it’s not going to work if they’re not.” Probation officers alluded to system mistrust and misunderstanding of their role as some of the reasons for resistance to partnerships; sometimes, system mistrust is related to the caregivers’ own experiences with the justice system. As one intake officer explained “Some of the kids that we work with, their parents have been through the system as well, and so their response to the system is how they interacted with it when they were in it.” One probation supervisor recognized that the system’s communication of expectations is not always effective:
We would like to have a partnership with the parents. I don’t think a lot of times that it’s seen as that. I think from the court side and the probation officer’s side, I don’t think that we’re real good at building that partnership. It’s ‘you have to do X, Y, Z. This is what your child has to do. These are what the requirements are.’ Instead of trying to develop goals together and working more towards a partnership.
Probation officers also recognized that family functioning and practical barriers that families face can be a barrier to engagement. Probation officers admitted that while their expectation for caregivers is to “act as parents”, this is sometimes a challenge, as there is often family dysfunction and stress. One probation supervisor’s comment summarizes this theme:We just look at it like we’re only asking you to do two things. Two things that a normal functioning family and normal functioning parents should be able to do. But then on the other side of it now, for that family who may or may not be functioning normally, or whatever normal is, that might be overwhelming. We may be not looking at some of the other factors and some of the other barriers about why they aren’t getting something done.
Caregiver Navigator Program
Caregivers, FCC members, and JJ personnel were also asked about the acceptability of a potential peer-based navigator program to support caregivers currently involved in the JJ system as a way to improve caregiver experiences and engagement with the system. All participants saw potential benefits of using such a program in the JJ system and highlighted that the program could provide important practical and social support to caregivers.
Participants highlighted the benefit of having someone who had been through the system themselves as a resource to better understand system processes and give advice. One caregiver described the potential benefit of offering informational and practical support: “If they’re anything like me they don’t know what’s going on. And you need that kind of advice and – from somebody that’s already been through it and is familiar with it.” Other caregivers also noted the potential for navigators to offer other general parental support and advice. One caregiver explained “It would be nice to talk to other mothers, fathers about what our children are going through and give any advice that they might have on how to – you know, what do you do to prevent this from happening again?” JJ personnel also noted the potential benefit of navigators in being responsible for providing resources: “If it’s someone that they’ve trusted and they’ve gone through the system… they would probably take it [resources, advice] more from that person than me.”
Participants also noted the potential benefit of offering emotional support given that system involvement is a stressful process. One caregiver explained, “It’s easier for [caregivers] to discuss their issues amongst each other, than to discuss with probation officers and the justice system.” One probation officer similarly described the role of a navigator in providing emotional and informational support: “Being that sounding board. Being that support piece as well as kind of an information [source].” Another FCC member summarized as follows: “Be an advocate. Sit at the table with them.”
Despite the largely positive feedback of the navigator program, both caregivers and JJ personnel cautioned that the program may not benefit everyone. Both caregivers and JJ personnel identified that offering such a program could be perceived as just another court requirement and add additional stress rather than providing support. Caregivers and JJ personnel also cautioned that some caregivers may perceive navigators as intrusive and as trying to tell caregivers how to be parents. For example, as one careviger explained: “There’s some parents…they don’t want to listen to nobody. It’s my child, I will raise them whichever way and nobody could tell me.”
CC BY 4.0. "Caregiver and Juvenile Justice Personnel Perspectives on challenges and importance of caregiver engagement and the potential utility of a peer navigator program in the Juvenile Justice System" by Dir AL, Pederson C, Khazvand S et al., Health & justice (2023). https://doi.org/10.1186/s40352-023-00231-y. Licensed under CC BY 4.0 (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/). Peer-reviewed and open access; full text from PubMed Central (PMC10403869). Headings and layout adapted for reading; figures and tables are in the original.